After a while I never believed I would leave. I decided I would never leave. Sometimes
the soldiers would tell me I would be released; but I never believed them. 65
After five years in detention, Jibran was finally released in 2009, at the age of 21. According to
Jibran, upon his release, a U.S. military officer apologized for capturing and detaining him.
I asked the officer with me why they were freeing me and where they were sending
me. His name was Lt Col Hendricks I think. He said the U.S. wanted to free me in
2007 because of a lack of evidence but Pakistan did not want me back. He
apologized for capturing me. I replied that this detention has stolen five years of my
life; your apology is not very helpful. How do I get those five years back? 66
b) Indefinite detention and repercussions for families
With detainees absent for years, parents have been left without their sons, and wives without their
husbands. For all the families interviewed, their relative’s detention meant they are robbed of
someone who provided substantial financial support, and was often the family’s primary
breadwinner. Many are large, traditional families with relatives living together in the same house,
often in Pakistan’s urban slums or poor rural areas where families must pool their incomes to make
ends meet. The loss of a major income earner has forced young children to give up their education
and elderly family members to return to the workforce. Torn from their relatives, struggling to earn
a living, and sometimes ostracized by their own communities, families bear a heavy burden, and do
not know when or if their lives will ever return to normal.
Maqsood, from Punjab, Pakistan, married his wife, Nargis in 2008, just two years before he was
detained by U.S. forces. Because of his long history of mental illness, Maqsood had to look for work
far from his native village in Punjab. Prior to his capture, he was employed on a water-boring project
in Chamman near the Afghanistan-Pakistan border, returning to his home in Punjab every three
weeks. However, due to his psychiatric condition, Maqsood would occasionally wander off, leaving
his family for weeks at a time. His family believes that he unwittingly crossed the PakistanAfghanistan border and was captured by U.S. forces. 67 Maqsood told his family that U.S. guards said
he was captured and detained for crossing the border without documentation. 68
In a society where women living alone are frowned upon, without her husband Nargis was forced to
move in with her brother, Mukhtar. Already struggling to make ends meet, Mukhtar says that he has
taken on a significant financial load to provide for his sister:
I now have to take care of my sister as well as myself. It is very burdensome. It is not
acceptable that a married woman still lives with her brother. People shun us because
our relative is in prison. 69
65
Ibid.
Justice Project Pakistan interview with Jibran, November 2012 (real name, location withheld); ‘Lt Col
Hendricks’ is a pseudonym.
67
Justice Project Pakistan interview with Nargis and Mukhtar, November 2012 (names, location withheld).
68
Ibid.
69
Justice Project Pakistan interview with Mukhtar, November 2012 (real name, location withheld).
66
21