filings suggest the committee has been side-stepped altogether with the Director for Afghanistan at
the MFA now taking the lead in conducting negotiations. 228
Pakistani officials have also failed to consistently confirm detainees’ nationality, adding significant
delay and complications to the repatriation process. Although the Pakistani embassy in Kabul was for
years communicating via diplomatic notes with its U.S. counterparts, it refused to formally recognize
detainees as Pakistani citizens when prompted by the United States. 229 It was only in response to an
order from the Lahore High Court that a formal process for confirmation of nationality was finally
established in 2012. Under this procedure, the Pakistani embassy in Kabul was made responsible for
initial nationality assessments with further confirmation provided by the Ministries of Foreign Affairs
and Interior in Islamabad. 230 However, confirmation of Pakistani detainees’ nationality still remains
an obstacle. In 2012, the Pakistani government officially confirmed the nationality of two detainees.
In August 2012, shortly before their repatriation was due, the Pakistani embassy reneged on the
government’s confirmation, which risked bringing the repatriation of those detainees to a
standstill. 231 Their repatriation proceeded only after the ICRC intervened, and obtained nationality
documents from the detainees’ families. 232
Interviews with U.S. officials also point to confusion on the U.S. government side of the negotiating
table. In an interview with JPP, one U.S. official stated that the DOD is solely responsible for drafting
and vetting security assurances, with the State Department only transmitting assurances to and from
Pakistan. 233 Another official, however, contradicted this claim, insisting that the State Department is
deeply involved in vetting and assessing security assurances. 234 According to this official, the State
Department, being the point of contact between the U.S. and foreign governments, has “people on
the ground” who can correctly evaluate the feasibility of specific assurances and provide valuable
input to the vetting process. 235 After over a decade of managing such detentions, the roles and
responsibilities of different U.S. government agencies and officials in the repatriation negotiation
process remain somewhat unclear.
Internal bureaucratic confusion, ad hoc negotiations, and the lack of clear, consistent policies has
also meant critical issues like the transfer and use of evidence remain unresolved. 236 Because much
of this evidence is classified, and is often hearsay from U.S. military personnel or confidential
informants, it is unclear what evidence can or will be shared with Pakistani authorities and whether
such evidence would be admissible in Pakistani courts. 237 Similarly, there are questions as to what
evidence may be used as a basis for the imposition of security orders and restrictions on repatriated
detainees. 238 Though Pakistani law gives primacy to written evidence, practice dictates that the
written testimony of a witness has little to no evidentiary value if he does not corroborate his
228
Report filed by the MFA in Sultana Noon v. Federation of Pakistan, 20 February, 2013.
Justice Project Pakistan interviews with U.S. government officials (names, dates, locations withheld).
230
Report filed by the MFA in Sultana Noon v. Federation of Pakistan, 25 April, 2012.
231
Justice Project Pakistan interviews with U.S. government officials (names, dates, locations withheld).
232
Ibid.
233
Justice Project Pakistan interview with U.S. government officials (names, dates, locations withheld).
234
Justice Project Pakistan interview with a U.S. government official (name, date, location withheld).
235
Ibid.
236
Justice Project Pakistan interviews with U.S. government officials (names, dates, locations withheld).
237
Human Rights First, “Detained and Denied”, ps. 9-10.
238
Justice Project Pakistan interviews with U.S. government officials (names, dates, locations withheld).
229
52
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents