imprisonment and four months had passed by that time. I thought there is
no harm in signing it now as only a little time of my sentence was left.15
A third detainee, Kamran, said that he accepted his 10-day sentence for fighting and
drinking alcohol during his first hearing because he feared contesting the ruling would
prisoners who refused to
sign the [document] stay in jail for a longer time, so I signed it at that time. The judge
keeps sending them back to jail every time they refuse thus this prolongs their stay in
16
Naveed said that other prisoners instructed him to accept his sentence as soon as
, as my case was not
a big offense. Otherwise, they would keep doing this to me and would not give me a proper
17
sentence. Therefore, it was better to get a s
No Legal Assistance
s Law on Criminal Procedure,
ight to seek the
assistance of a lawyer or a representative to defend him during the investigation and trial
stages. 18 In addition, the Arab Charter on Human Rights, which Saudi Arabia ratified in
2009, guarantees the right to free lawyers and interpreters.19 However, in only one of the
19 criminal cases documented by Justice Project Pakistan and Human Rights Watch did the
defendant have access to a defense lawyer during part of his criminal case. Saudi Arabia
does not have a public defender service nor any state support to lawyers who assist those
who cannot afford private lawyers.
In most cases interviewees said that it was difficult to obtain legal representation because,
unlike Saudi detainees, they had no access to individuals on the outside who could
facilitate contact with a lawyer. In addition, most lacked financial resources. Even
individuals facing the death penalty for drug-related offenses did not have legal
representation or someone to assist them during the legal process. Likewise, Pakistani
defendants without lawyers almost never had access to trial documents or court records.
15
Justice Project Pakistan interview with Ghulam, Faisalabad, November 17, 2015.
16
Justice Project Pakistan interview with Kamran, Narowal, November 19, 2015.
17
Justice Project Pakistan interview with Naveed, December 6, 2015.
18
Law of Criminal Procedure, art. 4.
19
Arab Charter for Human Rights, art 16.4.
15
MARCH 2018