he and his family do not “know anything about his release—we do not know how or when it is
happening.” 103
Some families were aware of some of the basic logistics of release—but knew nothing about the
actual negotiations and substantive political and legal process that could actually lead to their
return. As one family member explained:
The ICRC has explained the process to me. First he will be released to the Embassy’s
custody. Then he will be given to the ICRC who sends him to Islamabad via an ICRC
plane. They told me that the ISI [Pakistan’s foreign intelligence agency] might hold
him for three days. I have no further information; that is all they told me. 104
When asked who they believe should inform them about the repatriation and review process,
families of Pakistani detainees hold the Pakistani government chiefly responsible. Yet, according to
family members, Pakistani officials have largely failed to do so. 105
Pakistani officials have consistently failed to provide families with an explanation of the repatriation
process, the negotiations with the United States, or made clear that their relatives’ fate ultimately
hinge on those negotiations. One family member said that in response to their inquiries, the Ministry
of Foreign Affairs simply told them that “the detainees have DRB hearings. The results are sent to
Washington where they decide whether or not to give the detainees back to their home countries
[…] That is all they told me. I just know that [the detainees] are given to the embassy and then
brought back.” 106
With little to no assistance from their own government, or the United States, families must rely on
JPP lawyers as well as the ICRC for limited guidance and updates. With little to no direct contact with
those actually responsible for the fate of detainees, families feel abandoned and helpless, eager for
the even the most basic information and understanding of what will happen.
Fareed, a land-owner living near Quetta, Balochistan and cousin of a current detainee, says that
after years of trying to get the Pakistani government to do more, his family has lost hope. “Talking to
politicians might help. But we cannot do it. Someone has to help us do that. They will not listen to
us.” 107 As an ethnic Baloch, Fareed and his family believe Pakistani authorities are even less likely to
help them. “The government is not going to help us, especially since we are Baloch.” 108
Other family members erroneously believed that after the DFIP was handed over to the Afghan
government, as had been announced by the U.S. and Afghan governments, their relatives would
finally be released. Before his brother was detained at the DFIP, Gul Nawaz used to listen to music
on the radio every night. Now he listens to the news, anxious to hear about developments, and was
heartened when he heard that the United States was handing over the DFIP, believing it would
expedite his brother’s repatriation:
103
Justice Project Pakistan interviews with relatives of current detainees (names, dates, locations withheld).
Justice Project Pakistan interview with Fareed, December 2012 (real name, location withheld).
105
Justice Project Pakistan interviews with relatives of current detainees (names, dates, locations withheld).
106
Justice Project Pakistan interview with Pirzada, March 2013 (real name, location withheld).
107
Justice Project Pakistan interview with Fareed, December 2012 (real name, location withheld).
108
Justice Project Pakistan interviews with Asif and Fareed, December 2012 (real names, location withheld).
104
29
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents