VI.
Recommendations
To the Government of Pakistan and the Government of the United States
•
Hold quarterly meetings between high-level U.S. and Pakistani officials to negotiate and
finalize a bi-lateral agreement for the repatriation of Pakistani detainees. Officials should at
minimum include relevant representatives from each country’s embassies in Kabul and
Islamabad, the U.S. State Department and Department of Defense, and the Pakistani
Ministry of Interior and Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
•
Sign a comprehensive, public bi-lateral agreement on the repatriation of Pakistani detainees
held by the United States that:
o
Requires U.S. military to notify the Pakistani embassy in Kabul of the detention of a
Pakistani citizen within 72 hours of their capture or of a detainee’s request to notify,
subject to the consent of the detainee, and that the Pakistani government officially
verify and confirm the detainee’s nationality within 60 days of capture;
o
Guarantees detainees access to Pakistani consular officials as well as access to
independent legal counsel while in U.S. detention;
o
Ensures that humane treatment assurances are assessed on an individualized basis
taking into account relevant factors including a detainee’s age, ethnicity, religion,
suspected militant activity or affiliation while also relying on previously agreed upon
assurances and measures that have been determined to sufficiently mitigate the risk
of torture upon return for detainees in a similar situation;
o
Ensures that an independent, third-party monitoring body as well as detainees’ legal
counsel are allowed to conduct unfettered, confidential, private, and unannounced
visits of any detainee returned to Pakistani custody from the date of his transfer
onwards;
o
Guarantees Pakistani judicial oversight of detainees’ access to counsel and monitors’
access to detainees and detention facilities by Supreme Court or High Court justices
with judicial findings and judicial orders made public;
o
Specifies the nature and substance of the security assurances that the Pakistani
government is providing to mitigate the security risk detainees are believed to pose
to the United States following their return to Pakistan;
o
Ensures any such security assurances are in full compliance with the Fundamental
Rights provided to Pakistani citizens under the Constitution of the Islamic Republic
of Pakistan, 1973, and implemented in accordance with due process provided under
Pakistani law and international human rights law, including the fair opportunity to
challenge the imposition of any security restrictions and guarantee that detainees
57
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents