It is through the institutionalization of such programming that the government can legitimately
argue that it has a means to prevent recidivism. While none of the Pakistani detainees in Bagram
were charged in the end, and most were captured on false suspicion, some admitted they were
travelling to Afghanistan to join the jihad. These detainees and their families serve as case studies
for understanding the impact of proximity to the war on terror as part of the larger history of
widespread violence across FATA. The violence of detention is not limited to the torture and abuse
that take place in captivity. Detainment psychologically impacts former prisoners long after they are
released, and also results in physical and mental health problems among family members involved
in caregiving, leaving those around them at a loss for how to help. The use of this analysis would be
informative for policy level decisions to prevent further use of detention to try suspected militants,
and for the reintegration of victims of such violence and trauma.
Addressing socioeconomic disenfranchisement
Socioeconomically underprivileged, detainees and their families were unable to access appropriate
healthcare, and simply had to continue living without treatment and medicine. Families reported
further economic hardship with the main income earner detained for years. Following their return,
their physical health deteriorated, and most, mentally unstable due to the abuse and trauma they
had suffered, were unable to find or maintain jobs. The first Bagram report recommended income
support and housing assistance of 10,000 PKR (USD 64) per month, but this has not seen fruition.
FATA is a region which has seen historic disenfranchisement and conflict, particularly in the last
fifteen years. The people of the region, including detainees and their families, need to be provided
monetary compensation that allows them to sustainably rebuild their lives. Understanding the
detainees’ experiences, then, is about more than hearing their stories of torture and abuse at
the hands of American jailers and DRB administrators. It is about understanding how history and
disempowerment engineered through government-directed structural and political violence have
put an entire region and its people through violence and in proximity of violence. Abduction and
detainment in Bagram are one of many everyday risks FATA residents live around. Residents of
FATA are routinely conceptualized by state elements within a framework of violence despite their
demands for normative integration.
60
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents