again, in the far north of the city, in a locality called Kati Pahari. The area was extremely crowded
and appeared to be a warzone with broken roads, barricaded on either side. “I was delighted to be
back,” Mushtaq said, “but it was no longer the same. My life after Bagram will never be normal. The Red
Cross promised me medical treatment for 6 months, and did nothing. They promised me that they would
set up a business for me, but nothing of the sort ever happened. They were all lies — all the promises that
they made in Bagram. And till now agencies still kidnap me. I still feel that I am not free.”
Mushtaq’s home was small, and we met in an even smaller room, sitting on two beds – the only
furniture – to chat with his three brothers. All his life, Mushtaq said he had traveled from Karachi
to Quetta. This time, recounting the details of his capture, Mushtaq recalled his abduction taking
place earlier, before even getting a chance to track down his father’s former business partner. He
entered Afghanistan by bus and was on his way to the province of Zabul when he was stopped
at a checkpost and the police asked him for his passport. As he did not own a passport, he gave
them his Pakistani CNIC. In response, they removed him from the bus, along with a 15-year-old
Afghan boy. They took them to a room next to the checkpost and began beating him. Kept here for
approximately ten days, they were regularly beaten, while Mushtaq believed the officers hatched a
plot in which he would be a suicide bomber and the young boy his guide. He was held captive for
a few more days before US soldiers arrived to transport him to Bagram.
In 2019, we met Mushtaq again and he told us that his Fourth Schedule status was making it very
difficult for him to travel freely in Karachi. For one, he has to remain in the vicinity of a specified
police station to report his presence on a weekly basis. If he needs to travel outside of the city or
area that is not in the jurisdiction of his police station, he first has to inform the said station. “Last
year, my mother became ill due to asthma. Someone informed me there is a healer in Quetta who has
a special medicine.” Mushtaq managed to secure permission to travel to Quetta, but on his return
journey was arrested by “some agency people”. Kept in custody in an unknown location for 40 days,
he suffered seizures. He explained that he was tried in court under Pakistan’s anti-terrorism act in
a trial that took six months to conclude, and that fortunately he was released.
Mushtaq lamented suffering from both physical and mental health issues, including back pain,
stomach ulcers, and continued seizures. He believed these problems began after the news of his
father’s death. He was also unable to work for long due to these ongoing health problems. He
borrowed a rickshaw from his friend for a few months and tried to make some money, but soon
suffered severe back pain and had to quit. Instead, he sold his only bike as he was in urgent need
of money, to cover expenses such as the 5,000 PKR (USD 32) monthly rent. To look for a more
affordable place in a different area of the city is impossible since he cannot shift due to the inclusion
of his name in the Fourth Schedule.
“What did you miss the most in Bagram?” we asked.
“I missed my freedom,” said Mushtaq.
49
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents