Mushtaq Ayub, the loan
Mushtaq Ayub worked as a labourer in Karachi. His father ran a cloth shop in Benares, a locality
in the city’s Orangi area known for its Indian namesake’s silk textiles. His business partner was an
Afghan who left in 1984, Mushtaq explained, when the store was destroyed in a fire that razed
the entire market area. When Mushtaq was about 24 or 25 years old, the family was confronted
with severe financial difficulties. His father, the main income earner of the family, fell ill and was
confined to bed. He thus asked Mushtaq to travel to Afghanistan to collect an old debt from his
former business partner. Narrating the circumstances that led to his capture, Mushtaq said, “The
business partner hadn’t paid my father back so my father sent me to retrieve his money — about 1-2 lakh
rupees. My father gave me the address on a piece of paper. But when I reached Afghanistan, this man
went into hiding. I later found him; he told me that I should go back and that he would bring my father
his money himself.” On his return journey, Mushtaq said he was stopped at a checkpoint near an
area close to Kabul and upon failure to produce a passport, the police took him (and a 15-year-old
Afghan boy travelling with him) into custody. Mushtaq suspected his father’s old business partner
complained to the Afghan authorities, suggesting Mushtaq had terrorist links in an effort to avoid
repaying his debt. “I was innocent but I was behind bars from 2005 to 2014. My father passed away in
2007. I had even forgotten my family’s faces,” said Mushtaq.
Mushtaq’s mother, Rang Mahal’s home is in an alley in Orangi Town, just off another narrow street.
She is an overweight woman and has difficulty moving. Some of her teeth are missing and she
smiles a lot. There are narrow stairs leading up to their modest home which is made up of a small
courtyard, a kitchen (about four by eight feet), a bathroom, and two rooms that serve dually as
bedrooms and living rooms. The ceilings of both of these rooms are painted with colourful designs,
decorated by the previous occupants to celebrate a family wedding. Now, two garlands made of
shiny wrapping paper and plastic flowers are pinned on one of the walls. One belongs to Saifullah’s
brother, who is married, and the other has been waiting for Mushtaq — for his wedding day.
When his father was alive, he used to suffer from paralysis, explained the family, and Mushtaq
would take him to a clinic about two kilometres from their house for treatment. His sister Mariam’s
husband worked there. Mushtaq was a very responsible son, and would not have been involved in
anything knowing that his father was unwell, and that his parents love him, and depend on him for
(financial) support. But they had accumulated a lot of debt since Mushtaq’s absence. Shopkeepers
stopped giving anything to the family on credit because of the money they owed.
Mushtaq’s grandmother remembered the day he disappeared differently. He had accompanied his
father to the hospital because he was sick. Mushtaq told his father that he would return to pick him
up, but he had not been seen since. “He was a well-mannered boy,” she went on to say, “and loved by
all. He regularly went for Quran classes and in his spare time he loved to play cricket and football with
the other children in the neighbourhood.” The rest of the family also added that Mushtaq dutifully
listened to whatever his mother asked of him. He worked as a labourer to help the family financially.
Upon repatriation in 2014, Mushtaq was jailed for three months in Karachi. In 2015, we met Mushtaq
48
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents