the Indian government has accused Pakistan of dragging its feet on the matter, the case
demonstrates the possibility of transmitting evidence for prosecutions and interpreting the ATA
1997 as applicable to acts committed outside of Pakistan. 196
There is some concern within the U.S. government that security assurances relying on the prospect
of terrorism prosecutions of detainees would be insufficient because of the high acquittal rate of
ATCs, estimated by some to be 75 percent. 197 However, it is important to remember that the
definition of terrorism under the ATA 1997 includes more traditional criminal acts not associated
with terrorism such as kidnapping for ransom, stoning, throwing bricks, and extortion. 198 These cases
represent a significant proportion of ATC caseload, undermining the accuracy of acquittal rates in
cases more traditionally associated with terrorism. 199 One of the main causes of the high acquittal
rate, witness intimidation, would be less likely in DFIP detainees’ cases, which would presumably rely
on physical and forensic evidence and witnesses outside Pakistan. 200 However, the U.S. and Pakistani
governments would have to agree on how to transfer evidence and measures to allow witnesses to
testify in court, such as testimony via video-link.
Any prosecution must fully respect detainees’ due process rights, as protected by Pakistani domestic
and international law. 201 Prosecutions should be based on evidence that is admissible in Pakistani
courts. 202 As per Pakistani law, any evidence—including classified evidence transmitted by the U.S.
government to Pakistani prosecutors—must be recorded in the presence of the accused. 203 Hearsay
“India urges Pakistan to speed up Mumbai attacks trial”, BBC News, 31 August, 2012,
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-19432829.
196
Lydia Polgreen and Souad Mekhennet, “Militant network is intact long after Mumbai siege”, The New York
Times, 29 September, 2009,
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/30/world/asia/30mumbai.html?_r=0&pagewanted=all; “Pakistan has not
done enough on attacks”, The Wall Street Journal, 23 November, 2009,
http://www.livemint.com/Politics/VVwBxLqgnXN2tSfGKUf94I/Pakistan-has-not-done-enough-on-attacks.html;
Zahid Gishkori, “2008 Mumbai attacks: Panel leaves for India to gather evidence”, The Express Tribune, 14
March, 2012, tribune.com.pk/story/349704/2008-mumbai-attacks-panel-leaves-for-india-to-gatherevidence/?print=true.
197
“75 pc acquittal rate in Pak terror trials: US report”, The Indian Express, 31 August, 2011,
http://www.indianexpress.com/news/75-pc-acquittal-rate-in-pak-terror-trials-us-report/839640/; State
Department, “Country reports 2012”, ps. 168.
198
Section 6(2)(e), (g), (k) Anti-Terrorism Act 1997.
199
Hassan Abbas, “Stabilizing Pakistan through police reform”, Asia Society, July 2012,
http://asiasociety.org/files/pdf/as_pakistan_police_reform.pdf, ps. 51-52.
200
State Department, “Country reports 2012”, ps. 168; Aatekah Mir-Khan & Asad Kharal, “Prosecuting
terrorists: out of 559 cases in 2012, suspects acquitted in 414”, The Express Tribune, 1 April, 2013,
tribune.com.pk/story/529353/prosecuting-terrorists-out-of-559-cases-in-2012-suspects-acquitted-in414/?print=true.
201
Article 10-A, Constitution of Pakistan, 1973; Article 10 Universal Declaration of Human Rights; Article 14
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
202
Under Pakistan law, evidence includes the examination-in-chief and cross-examination of witnesses. See
1994 Cr LJ 2026 (2031, 2033) (All); Santosh Dey v. Smt. Archana Cuha (1992) 2 Cal LT (HC) 1 : 1 Cal.
203
Section 353 Code of Criminal Procedure. It is however possible for the judge to order proceedings to be
held in camera, with only counsel present as per section 352 Code of Criminal Procedure.
48
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents