It should be noted that any post-transfer detention under the Action in Aid of Civil Power
Regulations 2011 (AACPR), which effectively legalized indefinite detention without charge or trial in
northwest Pakistan, would be a serious violation of detainees’ rights. The AACPR are in clear
violation of the Pakistani Constitution and fundamental rights. 188 The AACPR contains few
procedural guarantees, and those that exist are not implemented. 189 The AACPR are also in clear
violation of Pakistan’s international human rights obligations. 190 Furthermore, there are numerous
credible reports of human rights violations, including torture and enforced disappearance of
individuals held under the AACPR. 191 Any detainee held by the Pakistani government post-transfer
should be held in a manner fully consistent with their rights under the Pakistani constitution, and
pursuant to domestic criminal law.
Some security concerns could be addressed through prosecution of detainees transferred to
Pakistani custody, assuming the U.S. government has sufficient evidence and that such evidence is
admissible in Pakistani courts. For detainees suspected of committing or conspiring to commit acts in
Pakistan, prosecutions, whether through the criminal justice system or the special Anti-Terrorism
Courts (ATCs), should not raise significant legal issues, provided that the U.S. military’s evidence is
properly shared with the Pakistani government and is admissible in Pakistani courts. 192
For detainees suspected of committing unlawful acts in Afghanistan, prosecutions could be more
problematic. Though the Penal Code expressly allows for prosecuting Pakistani citizens for acts
committed abroad, there is ambiguity regarding the applicability of the Anti-Terrorism Act 1997 (ATA
1997)—Pakistan’s seminal counter-terrorism legislation—to acts committed abroad. 193 The ATA
1997 applies only to Pakistani territory and does not explicitly cover acts committed outside
Pakistan, except for directing terrorist activities in Pakistan while residing abroad. 194 On the other
hand, Pakistani prosecutors have used the ATA 1997 to prosecute individuals for acts committed
abroad. Individuals have been charged with planning and helping to execute the 2008 Mumbai
attacks under the Act and are being tried in the Anti-Terrorism Courts (ATCs) since 2009. 195 Though
188
“Promise of a post-Adiyala Pakistan”, Dawn, 12 March, 2012,
http://beta.dawn.com/news/702189/promise-of-a-post-adiyala-pakistan; Amnesty International, “Hands of
cruelty”.
189
Amnesty International, “Hands of cruelty”, ps. 41-44.
190
Ibid.; Article 9 Constitution of Pakistan 1973; Article 9 ICCPR.
191
Amnesty International, “Hands of cruelty”, ps. 18-30; Umer Farooq, “’Year for recovery of missing persons’
fails to hold its promise”, The Express Tribune, 1 January, 2013, http://tribune.com.pk/story/487159/year-forrecovery-of-missing-persons-fails-to-hold-its-promise/; Mudassir Raja, “Chambers of horror: Govt lifts lid on
secret K-P internment centres”, The Express Tribune, 10 July, 2013,
http://tribune.com.pk/story/574969/chambers-of-horror-govt-lifts-lid-on-secret-k-p-internment-centres/.
192
Sections 188, 189 Code of Criminal Procedure. As per section 12 Anti-Terrorism Act 1997, Anti-Terrorism
Courts have exclusive jurisdiction over offences under the Act. However, the decision to prosecute under the
Penal Code or under the Anti-Terrorism Act 1997 depends on the nature of the acts, evidence in the
prosecutor’s possession and prosecutorial discretion.
193
Sections 3, 4 Pakistan Penal Code; Section 188 Code of Criminal Procedure
194
Sections 1, 11-V Anti-Terrorism Act 1997.
195
“Pakistan charges seven people over Mumbai attacks”, BBC News, 25 November, 2009,
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8378281.stm; Saeed Shah & Richard Orange, “Mumbai attacks: Pakistan charges
seven men on eve of anniversary”, The Telegraph, 25 November, 2009,
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/india/6655560/Mumbai-attacks-Pakistan-charges-sevenmen-on-eve-of-anniversary.html; Matt Glenn, “Pakistan to begin trial of 5 Mumbai terror attack suspects”,
JURIST, 11 July, 2009, http://jurist.law.pitt.edu/paperchase/2009/07/pakistan-to-begin-trial-of-5-mumbai.php;
47
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents