Negotiations for transfer and control of the DFIP from U.S. to Afghan authorities began in 2010. As
these dragged on and the United States continued to maintain control over the facility and the
detainees, the Afghan government increasingly viewed the handover as a matter of national
sovereignty. 18 After several deadlines for the transfer of authority passed without a successful
handover, the Afghan government made control over the DFIP and Afghan detainees a precondition
for a Strategic Partnership Agreement (SPA). 19 The SPA provides a framework for continued
cooperation between the U.S. and Afghan governments after the 2014 drawdown. 20 It is also the
basis for negotiations of the Bilateral Security Agreement, which will authorize and govern the U.S.
military presence and operations in Afghanistan post-2014. 21
On 9 March, 2012, the governments of the United States and Afghanistan signed a Memorandum of
Understanding (Detentions MoU) to transfer control of the DFIP from the U.S. to the Afghan
government within six months. 22 However, disagreements over the meaning of key provisions of the
Detentions MoU arose, relating to detention authority over future captures and the adoption of an
Afghan internment regime. As a result, the United States failed to hand over full control of the DFIP
within the specified timeframe and suspended the detainee transfer process. 23 By late March 2013,
six months after the initial handover deadline had passed, the U.S. and Afghan governments signed a
new MoU which—according to the Afghan government—does not authorize detention without trial
and does not grant the United States a veto on detainee releases. 24 Both governments announced
that they had finally resolved their differences and completed the transfer of the DFIP and its
approximately 3,000 Afghan detainees. 25
However, the highly troubled handover of the DFIP only impacted Afghan detainees. 26 The United
States continues to have custody and full authority over roughly 60 TCNs, seemingly in contravention
18
“US unveils Bagram handover plan”, Al-Jazeera English, 27 February, 2010,
http://www.aljazeera.com/news/asia/2010/02/2010227134828232750.html.
19
Kate Clark, “The Bagram Memorandum: Handing over ‘the Other Guantanamo’”, The Afghanistan Analysts
Network, 21 March, 2012, www.aan-afghanistan.com/print.asp?id=2619.
20
Emma-Graham Harrison, “Afghanistan and US agree on strategic partnership document”, The Guardian, 22
April, 2012, http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/apr/22/afghanistan-us-strategic-partnership-document.
21
Ibid.
22
Ibid.
23
Open Society Foundations, “Remaking Bagram: The creation of an Afghan internment regime and the Divide
over U.S. detention power”, 6 September, 2012,
http://www.opensocietyfoundations.org/sites/default/files/BagramReportEnglish.pdf; “US army hands over
Bagram”, BBC News, 25 March, 2013.
24
Kate Clark, “The Other Guantanamo 5: A New MoU for Bagram and, Finally a Handover”, The Afghanistan
Analysts Network, 24 March 2013, www.aan-afghanistan.org/print.asp?id=3310. Unlike the 2012 MoU, the
2013 is a classified document. Therefore, it remains unclear whether the 2013 MoU actually resolves the core
disputes between the two governments that led to the initial suspension of the handover - including the
legality of internment under Afghan law, U.S. veto power over releases and the process for handling detainees
captured in post-handover U.S. operations.
25
“US army hands over Bagram” BBC News, 25 March, 2013.
26
Open Society Foundations, “Remaking Bagram: The creation of an Afghan internment regime and the Divide
over U.S. detention power”, 6 September, 2012,
http://www.opensocietyfoundations.org/sites/default/files/BagramReportEnglish.pdf. The 2012 MoU is
vaguely worded and does not explicitly exclude TCNs from handover of detainees from the U.S. to Afghan
authority; however, Afghan and U.S. officials at the time agreed separately that the 2012 MoU did not apply to
TCNs. Given that the MoU signed in 2013 is classified, it is unknown whether it too carves out an exception for
continued U.S. detention of TCNs.
12