practices, including kidnapping in Pakistan by bounty hunters or intelligence officers seeking
bounties and false accusations by Afghan co-workers for monetary gain or due to personal enmity,
led to the detention of their relatives, raising serious concern that these detainees might be
wrongfully held. 176
There are cases where it appears that the U.S. military relied in part on circumstantial evidence—
such as mere presence in or proximity to a compound believed to be used by militants and
terrorist—to justify capture and detention. 177 In the case of a Pakistani detainee released in 2012, a
U.S. official confirmed to JPP interviewers that he was actually taken hostage by militants, and
mistakenly detained by U.S. forces when they raided the compound in which he was being held. 178
The official added that the U.S. military interrogated him only after his transfer to the DFIP and
conducted little to no investigation. 179
For Afghan detainees, witness participation is easier. The U.S. military provides support to witnesses,
including financial assistance for travel. The U.S. military and explains the DRB process and the
purpose of witness testimony, and engages frequently with the Afghan government and population.
This allows detainees to more easily present information, such as evidence of past enmity or
character testimonies, crucial to elucidating cases of wrongful detention and mitigating U.S. security
fears. 180 Moreover, evidence suggests that detainees who call witnesses have a lower chance of
being recommended for continued internment, indicating that witnesses are crucial to mitigating
U.S. threat perception. 181
By contrast, witness participation for Pakistani detainees is sorely lacking. One U.S. government
official admitted that witness participation at the DRB is skewed in favor of Afghan detainees. 182
Relatives of Pakistani detainees are unaware of how exactly they can meaningfully participate in DRB
proceedings. 183 Attorneys’ eagerness to contribute to the DRB is stifled by the DOD’s limited
cooperation and unwillingness to respond to requests of DRB transcript disclosures. In addition, the
Pakistani government refuses to participate in DRB proceedings, even upon detainees’ express
“Detained and Denied”, ps. 14-19. A large number of Pakistani detainees were captured when the use of
bounties was widespread.
176
Justice Project Pakistan interviews with the relatives of Kaleem, Ibrahim, Javed, Abdul Jabbar, Murtaza and
Muhammad (real names, dates, locations withheld). For evidence that Pakistani officials or elements of the
Pakistani government and security services claimed bounties see: Pervez Musharraf, “In the line of fire: a
memoir”, 25 September, 2006, p. 237 (“We have earned bounties totaling millions of dollars. Those who
habitually accuse us of “not doing enough” in the war on terror should simply ask the CIA how much prize
money it has paid to the government of Pakistan.”).
177
Human Rights First, “Detained and denied”, ps. 14-15; Open Society Foundations, “The cost of kill/capture:
Impact of the night raid surge on Afghan civilians”, 19 September, 2011,
http://www.opensocietyfoundations.org/sites/default/files/Night-Raids-Report-FINAL-092011.pdf, ps. 9-15.
178
Justice Project Pakistan interview with a U.S. government official (name, date, location withheld).
179
Ibid.
180
Justice Project Pakistan interview with a U.S. government official (name, date, location withheld);
Lieutenant Colonel Jeff A. Bovarnick, “Detainee Review Boards in Afghanistan: From Strategic Liability to
Legitimacy”, The Army Lawyer, June 2010, http://www.loc.gov/rr/frd/Military_Law/pdf/BovarnickDetainee.pdf, ps. 34-35.
181
Lieutenant Colonel Jeff A. Bovarnick, ”Detainee Review Boards in Afghanistan”, p. 35
182
Justice Project Pakistan interview with a U.S. government official (name, date, location withheld).
183
Justice Project Pakistan interviews and conversations with relatives of current detainees (names, dates,
locations withheld).
45
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents